Boats for sale in Shelter Island New York

From bow to stern, every detail of the 700 Series from Evotti has been crafted with premium materials and modern design touches that elevate your time on the water. This Saltwater... View Details

Saltwater Edition now on order! This Tritoon is powered by the 250hp Yamaha V-Max SHO and built as a Saltwater Edition with Sealed Lifting Strakes and Saltwater Anodes for added du... View Details

Powered by the 250hp Yamaha V-Max SHO, this Tritoon offers room for 11 passengers with two forward Chaise Loungers and a 7-Position Stern Lounger that delivers flexibility for host... View Details

Let us introduce you to the RX Sport! New to Bennington for 2024 is the Phantom Black interior! This boat also features the ALL NEW Yamaha 350hp V-6 engine! This is TRULY a MUST... View Details

Introducing to the color lineup for 2025 Bennington, is the new Olaedo Gold, paired with the smooth silver panel on this sharp looking 18 foot Bennington! 2025 Bennington 18 SLXSX... View Details

Experience Bennington's signature series, the "Bowrider" with the industry's only step down bow! This boat comes with a brand new 250hp engine and a bunk trailer! 2021 Bennington... View Details

This Bennington is loaded with options and is in the water, available for immediate test drives! Paired with the ultra reliable 200hp Yamaha VMAX SHO 2021 Bennington 22 LSB18'-25'... View Details

Quad Bench Tritoon paired with the ultra reliable 150hp Yamaha engine! Features include 12 button digital switching, Captain/Co-Captain's High Back Recliners and Ski Tow Bar with a... View Details

We're excited to welcome the all-new Bennington M Series to our lineup! This sleek model has a Matte Black exterior with the Absolute Red accent panel and can be powered up to 250h... View Details

New to the color lineup for 2026 is Verdell Green! Stop by the dealership to view this Quad Bench layout that prioritizes comfort, more seating and optimal storage. This boat is pa... View Details

The L-bench pontoon layout has benches up front and a spacious L-bench midship allowing for multiple conversation areas! Paired with the 90hp Yamaha engine, features include lighte... View Details

New Arrival! Swingback Tritoon with 150hp Yamaha engine & Saltwater Package! Whether you're cruising the lake or heading into saltier waters, this tritoon offers comfortable seatin... View Details

Gorgeous Luminous Blue/Metallic White Bennington with the blackout package paired with the Yamaha 90hp engine just arrived! Ask us about the new Lillipad ladder! 2026 Bennington S... View Details

Check out this 16ft Bennington with the popular Swingback floorplan! Features include Blackout package and upgraded Lillipad ladder, ensuring easy boarding for people and dogs! Pai... View Details

This Bennington pontoon features the "L-Bench" layout which includes benches up front and a spacious L-bench midship allowing for multiple conversation areas! This boat is paired w... View Details

Brand NEW 2021 15 Alaskan TL SS DLX with 2022 25HP Mercury. Boat is a demo and has less than three hours on it! Includes trailer, oars, battery and gas tank. I will also consider s... View Details

Stock #468423 Video of this vessel available at www [dot] popsells [dot] com/view/468423 Reason for selling is "Going bigger". This Grady-White has been on the market for more t... View Details

Stock #456373 Reason for selling is "not using". ANY and ALL offers will be put in front of our seller! Submit your offer today! Great running Signature 250! Low hours! Well mai... View Details

Stock #308516 Reason for selling is "Looking to buy a diffrent style and size". ANY and ALL offers will be put in front of our seller! Submit your offer today! 2017 Harris Solst... View Details

Stock #407393 Video of this vessel available at www [dot] popsells [dot] com/view/407393 Reason for selling is "Sellers are done with boating for now". ANY and ALL offers will b... View Details

Stock #276252 Video of this vessel available at www [dot] popsells [dot] com/view/276252 Reason for selling is "Buying a larger boat". ANY and ALL offers will be put in front of... View Details