Boats for sale in Shelter Island New York

Don’t miss out on this 2003 Four Winns H200 – a standout bowrider in a classic blue and white color combo from one of boating’s most trusted brands! This model is no longer in prod... View Details

Two incredible rides, endless fun on the water! These 2019 Yamaha VX Cruiser HO waverunners come fully featured and in great condition with less than 100 engine hours. Available as... View Details

Step aboard this 2019 Starcraft EXS 1, a versatile triple pontoon built for fun and relaxation. With ample seating, a smooth ride, and thoughtful features, this ride is ready to ma... View Details

Packed with popular features and a comfortable layout, this 2017 Starcraft Marine CX 21 C is a great value for anyone getting into boating! Features include full teak weave floorin... View Details

Classic fun never gets old! A true Lake Hopatcong original, this 1968 Donzi has only been used in freshwater. Impressively well-kept, this one-of-a-kind Deep V Sport Boat delivers... View Details

The Sea Ray 260 Sundancer is one of Sea Ray's most sought after models. Comfortable accommodations for 4, her amenities include ac/heat, windlass, pressure hot/cold water & a beaut... View Details

Stock #466502 Reason for selling is "Not Using". This Viaggio has been on the market for more than 30 days (Oct 6th). If you are thinking of making an offer, submit it today and... View Details

Stock #274240 Reason for selling is "Wants something newer and smaller". ANY and ALL offers will be put in front of our seller! Submit your offer today! 1989 Formula 35PC! In th... View Details

Stock #429160 This is a new advertisement, on the market just this week (Nov 26th). Always accepting offers! Why Buy New? Comes With a 2023 Load Rite Dual Axel Trailer Powered by... View Details

Stock #429150 Reason for selling is "No longer use it". ANY and ALL offers will be put in front of our seller! Submit your offer today! Low hours! Clean! Volvo Penta DuoProp! Si... View Details

Stock #470771 This Manitou has recently been added to market (Oct 29th). Submit your offer today! 22 Max Bench powered by Rotax 150 with low hours! Marine Mat flooring! Formed al... View Details

Looking for a versatile and well-maintained boat? This 2020 Boston Whaler 170 Montauk is an excellent choice for both fishing enthusiasts and families looking for some fun on the w... View Details

Stock #417448 ANY and ALL offers will be put in front of our seller! Submit your offer today! 2008 Chaparral 260 EX, Bowriders, Chaparral! 26' and Low 136 Hours, Runs Great! Thi... View Details

Stock #471592 Reason for selling is "Change of Plans". This Wellcraft has recently been added to market (Nov 17th). Submit your offer today! For sale is my 2003 Wellcraft 250 Fi... View Details

Stock #361991 Reason for selling is "Has another boat". ANY and ALL offers will be put in front of our seller! Submit your offer today! Rare BlackWatch 30 Express, Solid conditi... View Details

Stock #445419 This Crownline has now been on the market a couple months. Looking for any offers! Nicely maintained! Includes newer Aqua Marine flooring, triple battery system, an... View Details

Stock #462541 This Yamaha has now been on the market more than a month. Please submit your offer today! 2018 Yamaha 210SX jet boat powered by twin engines This 2018 Yamaha SX 21... View Details

Stock #387603 Reason for selling is "Change of plans". This Pacemaker has now been on the market more than a month. Please submit your offer today! Twin 7.4L Mercruisers, spacio... View Details

Stock #467427 Reason for selling is "Going Bigger". This Yamaha has now been on the market more than a month. Please submit your offer today! Loaded lift kept 2020 Yamaha AR240!... View Details

2025 Avalon 23' LSZ Quad Lounger Shift Platinum Edition Tri-toon, White Suzuki 150 HP CARIBBEAN Blue Walls, SILVER Flake Metallic 2nd wall color, Leon Silver Base Seat Vinyl, Leon... View Details

2025 23' Avalon Catalina Platinum Edition Versatile Rear Lounger TriToon Powered by Suzuki 200 HP 4 Stroke OutBoard with Electric Power Steering, Loaded with the goodies, Saltwater... View Details