Boats for sale in Shelter Island New York

Filters

Let’s talk about pre-qualifying for a boat loan

Boat ownership has never been more affordable or easier. Whether you are looking to purchase a new boat or refinance your existing loan, we can help.

Back

Filter

Price Drop
1993 Sea Ray 310 Sun Sport

$33,350

Clayville, NY
- Clayville, NY
- Express Cruiser
- 31' / 0'
- 1993 / Used
- $33,350
Stock #387927 Reason for selling is "Sellers are done with boating for now". ANY and ALL offers will be put in front of our seller! Submit your offer today! A great lake boat th... View Details

View 10 Photos and Details Contact Seller

$33,350
VIEW DETAILS
2024 Cobia 220 DC

$64,000

Cape May, NJ
- Cape May, NJ
- Fishing
- 22' / 0'
- 2024 / Used
- $64,000
Stock #468385 Reason for selling is "Updating Fleet". This Cobia has been on the market for more than 30 days (Oct 2nd). If you are thinking of making an offer, submit it today a... View Details

View 10 Photos and Details Contact Seller

$64,000
VIEW DETAILS
2024 Cobia 220 DC

$64,000

Cape May, NJ
- Cape May, NJ
- Fishing
- 22' / 0'
- 2024 / Used
- $64,000
Stock #468383 Reason for selling is "Updating Fleet". This Cobia has been on the market for more than 30 days (Oct 2nd). If you are thinking of making an offer, submit it today a... View Details

View 9 Photos and Details Contact Seller

$64,000
VIEW DETAILS
Advertisement
2024 Key West 239FS

$59,500

Cape May, NJ
- Cape May, NJ
- Fishing Center Console
- 23' / 0'
- 2024 / Used
- $59,500
Stock #468381 Reason for selling is "Updating Fleet". This Key West has now been on the market more than a month. Please submit your offer today! 2024 Key West 239FS powered by... View Details

View 9 Photos and Details Contact Seller

$59,500
VIEW DETAILS
2024 Key West 239FS

$59,500

Cape May, NJ
- Cape May, NJ
- Fishing Center Console
- 23' / 0'
- 2024 / Used
- $59,500
Stock #468379 Reason for selling is "Updating Fleet". This Key West has been on the market for more than 30 days (Oct 2nd). If you are thinking of making an offer, submit it toda... View Details

View 10 Photos and Details Contact Seller

$59,500
VIEW DETAILS
2023 Bayliner DX2200

$39,500

Cape May, NJ
- Cape May, NJ
- Deck Boat
- 22' / 0'
- 2023 / Used
- $39,500
Stock #394701 Reason for selling is "Updating Fleet". ANY and ALL offers will be put in front of our seller! Submit your offer today! The room of a pontoon boat on deck and a fi... View Details

View 9 Photos and Details Contact Seller

$39,500
VIEW DETAILS
2023 Bayliner DX2200

$39,500

Cape May, NJ
- Cape May, NJ
- Deck Boat
- 22' / 0'
- 2023 / Used
- $39,500
Stock #394293 Reason for selling is "Updating Fleet". ANY and ALL offers will be put in front of our seller! Submit your offer today! The room of a pontoon boat on deck and a fi... View Details

View 10 Photos and Details Contact Seller

$39,500
VIEW DETAILS
Advertisement
Advertisement
2023 Bayliner VR6 OB

$43,500

Cape May, NJ
- Cape May, NJ
- Bowrider
- 23' / 0'
- 2023 / Used
- $43,500
Stock #394756 Reason for selling is "Updating Fleet". ANY and ALL offers will be put in front of our seller! Submit your offer today! Good condition, 10 person capacity, & power... View Details

View 10 Photos and Details Contact Seller

$43,500
VIEW DETAILS
Advertisement
Price Drop
2023 Aquasport 22CC

$39,000

Cape May, NJ
- Cape May, NJ
- Fishing Center Console
- 22' / 0'
- 2023 / Used
- $39,000
Stock #394265 Reason for selling is "Updating Fleet". ANY and ALL offers will be put in front of our seller! Submit your offer today! Aquasport vessels are high-quality fibergla... View Details

View 9 Photos and Details Contact Seller

$39,000
VIEW DETAILS
Price Drop
2008 Larson Cabrio 330

$67,500

Cape May, NJ
- Cape May, NJ
- Express Cruiser
- 32' / 0'
- 2008 / Used
- $67,500
Stock #456938 Reason for selling is "Buying a Larger boat". ANY and ALL offers will be put in front of our seller! Submit your offer today! Excellent 2008 Larson Cabrio 330 Expr... View Details

View 10 Photos and Details Contact Seller

$67,500
VIEW DETAILS